| 360 | Ken Handel | 1989-1991 | | 348 | Noah Wood | 2014-2016 | | 288 | Nick Levinski | 2016-2018 | | 285 | Brad Mushrush | 1990-1992 | | 282 | Hunter Nice | 2012-2014 |
| | 146 | Ken Handel | 1991 | | 137 | Noah Wood | 2015 | | 136 | Brad Mushrush | 1991 | | 130 | Brad Mushrush | 1992 | | 127 | Nick Levinski | 2018 |
| | 23 | Brad Mushrush | 1992 | | 18 | Nick Levinski | 2017 | | 18 | Rob Basile | 2009 | | 17 | Aiden Whiteley | 2024 | | 16 | Rob Basile | 2009 | | 15 | Micah Kunkle | 2020 | | 15 | Nick Levinski | 2018 | | 15 | James Streapy | 2004 | | 15 | Hunter Nice | 2013 |
|
|
| 17 | Eric Mushrush | 1987-1989 | | 13 | Brian Wimmer | 2000-2002 | | 11 | Tyler Merwarth | 2018 - 2020 | | 11 | K Roberts | 2008-2009 | | 8 | Jon Potynski | 2013-2015 | | 8 | Tim Swartley | 1988-1989 |
| | 11 | Brian Wimmer | 2002 | | 9 | Eric Mushrush | 1988 | | 6 | John Eatherton | 2021 | | 6 | Kurt Roberts | 2009 | | 6 | Rick Steich | 1986 | | 6 | Kevin Laboski | 1986 | | 6 | Ken Slotter | 1969 |
| | 3 | Tyler Merwarth | 2019 | | 2 | Brady Martin | 2024 | | 2 | Tyler Merwarth | 2020 | | 2 | Justin Weider | 2011 | | 2 | Jon Potynski | 2015 | | 2 | Kyle Baskin | 2015 | | 2 | Tony Latronica | 2008 | | 2 | Hunter Nice | 2013 | | 2 | Kurtis Roberts | 2008 | | 2 | Tyler Kishbaugh | 2014 |
|
|
| 32 | Jeff Oakley | 1988-1990 | | 18 | Todd Gaffney | 2000-2001 | | 17 | Fred Retter | 2020-2021 | | 17 | Adam Weikert | 1997-1998 | | 16 | Harley Moyer | 2001-2002 | | 16 | Chris Messina | 1999-2000 |
| | 18 | Jeff Oakley | 1990 | | 15 | Fred Retter | 2021 | | 13 | Harley Moyer | 2002 | | 12 | Adam Weikert | 1998 | | 12 | Tom Hamilton | 1996 |
| | 4 | Fred Retter | 2021 | | 4 | Mason Schmauder | 2013 | | 4 | Micah Jones | 2014 | | 3 | William Bowen | 2024 | | 3 | Fred Retter | 2021 | | 3 | Jacob Goldman | 2016 | | 3 | Anthony Ferrugio | 2022 & 2023 | | 3 | Doug Kile | 2004 | | 3 | Todd Gaffney | 2000 | | 2 | Many Players Tied | N/A |
|
|
| 42 | Gavin Carroll | 2022 - 2024 | | 39 | Nick Levinski | 2016-2018 | | 38 | Noah Wood | 2014-2016 | | 36 | Hunter Nice | 2012-2014 | | 33 | Anthony Ferrugio | 2021-2023 | | 29 | Fred Retter | 2020-2021 |
| | 25 | Fred Retter | 2021 | | 23 | Hunter Nice | 2014 | | 20 | Rob Basile | 2009 | | 19 | Bryan Sherry | 2020 | | 19 | Demetrius Green | 2007 |
| | 7 | Bryan Sherry | 2020 | | 5 | Gavin Carroll | 2024 | | 5 | Julian Renner | 2020 | | 5 | Noah Wood | 2016 | | 4 | Jackson Connelly | 2024 | | 4 | Anthony Ferrugio | 2022 & 2023 | | 4 | Fred Retter | 2021 (2x) | | 4 | Kaden Roesner | 2021 | | 4 | Micah Kunkle | 2020 | | 4 | Nick Levinski | 2016 | | 4 | Micah Jones | 2014 | | 3 | 8 Players Tied | N/A |
|
|
| 5 | Nick Levinski | 2016-2018 | | 5 | Noah Wood | 2014-2015 | | 5 | Todd Gaffney | 1999-2001 | | 4 | B Awckland | 1988 | | 4 | Andrew Dietz | 2000 | | 4 | Jon Ruch | 2003 |
| | 4 | B Awckland | 1988 | | 4 | Andrew Dietz | 2000 | | 4 | Jon Ruch | 2003 | | 3 | 13 Players Tied | N/A |
| |
|
| 100 | Zach Schoch | 2004 | | 97 | Kurtis Roberts | 2008 | | 97 | Derek Ambler | 2005 | | 95 | Eric Mushrush | 1987 |
|
|
| 86 | Harley Moyer | 2002 | | 83 | Tom Hontz | 1983 | | 42 | Todd Schullberger | 1997 | | 34 | Chris Leister | 2004 |
|
|
| 108 | | 1990 (12 games) | | 90 | | 1988 (11 games) | | 35 | | 1921 (10 games) | | 34 | | 1956 (10 games) | | 20 | | 1936 (9 games) |
|
|
|
| 22 | | 2002 | | 19 | | 1993 | | 18 | | 1988 | | 18 | | 1991 | | 17 | | 1986 |
|
|
