2004 Season

James Streapy - 1st team LB
Dustyn Seifert - 2nd team DL
Nate Cox - 2nd team DB

2008 Season

Josh Barndt - 1st team OL

Eric Fath - 1st team TE

Tony Latronica - 1st team DB

Rob Basile - 2nd team LB

Geoff DeLan - 2nd team P

Kurtis Roberts - 2nd team DB

2007 Season

Jordan Waxman - 1st team Punter
Demetrius Greene - 2nd team DL

2005 Season

Caleb Ruch - 1st team DT
Derek Ambler - 2nd team DB
Dustin Fischer - 2nd team RB

2006 Season

Caleb Ruch - 1st team DT
Jordan Waxman - 1st team Punter

2003 Season

Chris Donley - 1st team QB
Jeremy Walck - 1st team OL
Nate Cox - 1st team WR
Dave Fischer - 2nd team RB
Ryan Walter - 2nd team WR
Jadd Buehrle - 2nd team OL