2004 Season

Dustyn Seifert - 1st team OG/DT
Nate Cox - 1st team WR
James Streapy - 1st team LB
Morgan Keller - 2nd team DB
Ryan Davis - 2nd team DT
Mike Devlin - 2nd team C
Jon Ruch - Honorable Mention QB
Nate Cox - Hon. Ment. DB
James Streapy - Hon. Ment. LB
Sean Viers - Hon. Ment. DB
Billy Whitehead - Hon. Men. TE/LB
Ryan Davis - Hon. Men. OG
Caleb Ruch - Hon. Men. OT/DT
Zach Schoch - Hon. Men. RB/P
Nate Miller - Hon. Men. K
Doug Kile - Hon. Men. ED
Mike Tomasino - Hon. Men. LB
Chris Leister - Hon. Men. LB
Derek Ambler - DB

2005 Season

* Won Sportsmanship Award
Caleb Ruch - 1st team OT/DT
Derek Ambler - 2nd team DB
Dustin Fischer - 3rd team RB
Derek Ambler - 3rd team WR
Justin Lightner - 3rd team OG
Scott Heilman - 3rd team DT
Jimmy Cartagena - 3rd team LB
Matt Donley - 3rd team DB
Jimmy Bowman - Hon. Men. QB
Matt Donley - Hon. Men. WR
Nate Sims - Hon. Men. TE
Jordan Waxman - Hon. Men. K
Justin Lightner - Hon. Men. DT
Chris Leister - Hon. Men. LB
Mike Tomasino - Hon. Men LB
Nate Dixon - Hon. Men. LB

2008 Season

Tony Latronica - 2nd team RB/DB

Eric Fath - 2nd team TE/DE

Josh Barndt - 2nd team OL/DL

Rob Basile - 2nd team LB

Geoff DeLan - 2nd team Punter

Kurtis Roberts - 2nd team DB

Kurtis Roberts - 3rd team WR

John Reimer - 3rd team OL

Ryan Tincknell - Honorable Mention QB

Edwin Gonzalez - Honorable Mention LB

2007 Season

Jon Courtney - 1st team OG

Demetrius Greene - 1st team DT

Jordan Waxman - 1st team Kicker/Punter

Nick Rosanelli - 2nd team C

Wes Watson - 2nd team DT

Tony Latronica - 2nd team DB

Tony Latronica - 3rd team RB

Timmy Jorgensen - 3rd team WR

Eric Fath - 3rd team TE

Wes Watson - 3rd team OT

Chase Karver - 3rd team LB

Jimmy Jordan - Honorable Mention WR

2006 Season

Caleb Ruch - 1st team OT/DT
Jimmy Cartagena - 1st team LB
Jordan Waxman - 1st team Kicker
Dustin Fischer - 2nd team RB
Nate Sims - 2nd team OT
Jordan Waxman - 2nd team Punter
Nate Dixon - 3rd team WR/DB
Kyle Ames - 3rd team TE
Brian Lorman - 3rd team OG
Brian Lorman - Honorable Mention DT
Dillon Gibat - Honorable Mention LB
Nate Hacker - Honorable Mention DE
Jimmy Cartagena - Honorable Mention RB
Dustin Weisel - Honorable Mention DT

2003 Season

Chris Donley - 1st team QB
Jeremy Walck - 1st team C/DT
Morgan Keller - 1st team DB
Nate Cox - 1st team WR
Dustyn Seifert - 1st team OG
Jadd Buehrle - 1st team OT
Dave Fischer - 2nd team RB/DB
Tom Gibat - 2nd team RB/LB
Dustyn Seifert - 2nd team DE
James Streapy - 2nd team LB
Ryan Walter - Honorable Mention WR/P
Jadd Buehrle - Honorable Mention DT
Brandon Shimp - Honorable Mention LB